zvi: self-portrait: short, fat, black dyke in bunny slippers (Default)
[personal profile] zvi
This is my thought for the Melee. I probably will not do it if I can't run it through the AO3, so this depends on how soon the next code push, with the prompt challenges, is available.

1) Authors submit stories they would like to have remixed. They may submit one each in up to five fandoms. (No crossovers!)

2) I number the list of all of the stories in each fandom. Using a random number generator, I select one story from each of the different fandoms. (I will do this sequentially, so that if one of your stories is picked, I remove you from the lists for all the other fandoms.)

3) I post all of the selected stories as prompts. So, there will be one Stargate Atlantis story in the melee, and one Leverage, and one Revolutionary Girl Utena, and one One Piece, and one RaPS, etc. etc. So that people who want to participate in the melee will select the fandom they want to work in, but then, as with participants in the Duello, they don't choose which author or which individual story.

Open to: Registered Users, detailed results viewable to: All, participants: 11

Sounds like a

View Answers

good idea
10 (100.0%)

bad idea
0 (0.0%)

I will participate in this version of the Melee. (0 = Not enough DW points in the world; 100 = I will pay you DW points to do it!)

View Answers
Mean: 50.00 Median: 55 Std. Dev 26.08
00 (0.0%)
102 (20.0%)
201 (10.0%)
300 (0.0%)
400 (0.0%)
502 (20.0%)
601 (10.0%)
702 (20.0%)
802 (20.0%)
900 (0.0%)
1000 (0.0%)


View Answers

9 (100.0%)

zvi: self-portrait: short, fat, black dyke in bunny slippers (Default)
[personal profile] zvi
I'm preparing to start round two of this challenge.

Some changes:

1) I now have a finer understanding of how mods can manipulate signups, so I think that I can now do away with required fandoms. Instead, people would make requests in multiple fandoms. However, everyone will need to recruit friends from the fandoms you plan on nominating, since I won't be assured of lots of overlap.

2) There are three possibilities for the Melee (people being able to do remixes without signing up or volunteering for their story to be remixed.)

A) I might just kill it. There is already a non-exchange, no deadline remix ([community profile] remix_goes_wild), so the accessibility issues I was trying to address are addressed elsewhere, and, with the change in signup, the small fandom issue I was trying to address last year is gone. Also, I wasn't very good at running it, and I dislike doing things I am not very good at.

B) If someone else has an idea of what should happen with it and would like to run it, you could. The only thing that I would ask you to do is run it through the AO3 as a prompt fest subcollection of Remix Duello. You could have whatever rules you wanted, and I wouldn't interfere, and I'd give you posting access on this comm. In effect, it would be a co-branded, contemporaneous exercise.

C) The reason for running [community profile] remixduello in the first place is to have a remix challenge with restraint, where the story you are to remix was picked for you, as an extra special remix challenge. (Also, to let you pick exactly which story got remixed, to say, "I want to see where someone takes that story.") The Melee got rid of both of those aspects of the challenge. I think a little bit of that could be restored if I reorganized it so that people could nominate stories as Melee prompts, but only one per fandom. Would that still be of interest to people?

Open to: Registered Users, detailed results viewable to: All, participants: 24

I am taking this poll because

View Answers

I am thinking about participating in the Remix Duello
15 (62.5%)

I am thinking about participating in the Melee
0 (0.0%)

it is on my reading page
9 (37.5%)

Regarding the Melee

View Answers

Let it fade away. It has been superseded by events.
3 (14.3%)

*grabby hands* I want to run it! Me, me, me!
0 (0.0%)

This "one per fandom" idea sounds interesting. Let's hear some more about that.
10 (47.6%)

I forgot what the Melee was from last year. What are you talking about?
6 (28.6%)

My response can not be captured in your limited array of poll answers. Please read my EPIC COMMENT on this matter.
2 (9.5%)

Favorite fandom

View Answers

9 (39.1%)

16 (69.6%)

Radio button
7 (30.4%)

5 (21.7%)

5 (21.7%)

Text entry
5 (21.7%)

I love all polls equally
10 (43.5%)

zvi: self-portrait: short, fat, black dyke in bunny slippers (Default)
[personal profile] zvi
Please only fill out this poll if you intend to participate in the Remix Duello (subject to time constraints, since I have not yet figured out the calendar.)

If you do not have a Dreamwidth account, you can log in with OpenID and vote in the poll. If that still doesn't work for you, post an anonymous comment with your answers.

a really long poll with only two questions )

June 2011

   1 234


RSS Atom

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Sep. 25th, 2017 03:05 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios